DA-FND-104:   
Karen Mitchell

What Would They Have Wanted?

Karen Mitchell is devastated to learn that her father was legally registered as an organ donor without ever discussing the decision with the family. She is not rejecting donation itself so much as struggling with whether a private legal decision should override what she believes should have been a family conversation. The advocate must build trust, acknowledge grief and fairness concerns, and explain first-person authorization without becoming procedural or argumentative.

Through the challenge of registered donor family opposition, the primary learning objectives are to:

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

  • Build trust before addressing donation concerns
  • Explore emotions and underlying objections
  • Respectfully explain first-person authorization
  • Remain calm during emotionally difficult conversations
  • Reduce conflict through active listening and empathy
Program

Donation Advocate

Target Audience

Donation Advocates 

Scenario Type

Family Member

Clinical Context

Brain Death

Registry Status

Registered

Difficulty

3

Experience Level

Intermediate

Emotional Intensity

Moderate

Conversation Style

First-Person Authorization, Family Conflict

Essential
Sim
Elements

Meet the simulation speaker

Karen Mitchell

Family member, Daughter
Robert Mitchell is a registered donor, but his daughter struggles with honoring a decision that was never discussed with the family.